Posted by troymcclure on 31. August 2005 - 21:05
I am curious.... does it matter who ripped off whom when the ad is this bad?
Please donate to keep adland alive. The Super Bowl Collection is the worlds one and only. It costs a minor fortune to keep up. If you love our efforts, please donate to keep the archive alive. You may also sponsor us with a large banner, advertise yourself as you help save our common advertising history.
Want to join adland?
Create an adgrunt account for 6 USD.
comments
- Why the hate? Ad is selling
34 min 30 sec ago - AntDude! *highfives*
And
5 hours 35 min ago - I think the "phase" market is
5 hours 41 min ago - Red Robin completely missed
7 hours 20 min ago - Let's see Peter Norton.
10 hours 31 min ago - ..!..
10 hours 42 min ago - Holy guy cave Batman, I am
12 hours 11 min ago - Ooh, you know what he's doing
14 hours 45 min ago - The ASCII doesn't work quite
15 hours 5 min ago - .............................
15 hours 9 min ago


...... and many moons later, I found another one to add to the bunch:
http://adland.tv/content/how-sell-hardware-stores-show-you-can-buy-tiny-...
*hahah* Consider it done Troy - congrats on your first front page post. wink
By all means, Dabitch, feel free to post these ads wherever you wish. And please - call me Troy. (Leers seductively.)
I quite like that catch troymcclure - mind if I move it (so it*s posted by you though) to the http://adland.tv/Badland pages?
McClain
Goodby
To be fair, I don*t know who is ripping off who here. Of course, it*s also possible that it could all be a coincidence - a freak occurance that defies the laws of man and nature, like Tunguska blast of 1908 or Paris Hilton*s celebrity.
Anyhow, if you visit Goodby*s site (www.goodbysilverstein.com), you*ll see a print ad for Ace Hardware (it*s ad #5) showing a tiny Ace salesman hanging on a tool rack. (The headline "Good advice is the best tool.")
Then, if you visit the website of a good yet somewhat obscure Denver agency named McClain Finlon (www.mcclainfinlon.com), you*ll see an ad for Xcel Energy Repair Care showing. . . a tiny repairman hanging on a tool rack. (The headline "Very handy appliance repair.")
It*s shocking how alike the visuals are. Like I said, I don*t which ad came first. All I do know is that I had bookmarked McClain*s site a couple of years ago (why, I don*t know) and that it doesn*t seem to have changed much since then - whereas I think the Ace ad is a relatively recent addition to Goodby*s canon.
If it Goodby did rip off McClain, it makes you wonder. I mean, first Mad Dogs and Englishmen, then McClain. Who*s next? Joe*s Advertising Shack?