Elephants and Mobile Phones.

Did these ads copy each other - or did the idea-god simply mess with two creative teams heads at the same time? Who knows.

Ben vs Hi

I'd like to use these as a perfect example of a coincidence, since I'm 99% sure that they are a complete coincidence. Made at roughly the same time at two different agencies in Amsterdam, it's funny how creatives think alike. " Mobile phone= small..What's quirky? I Know, Big = Elephant! Brief Solved!"

ben

It's difficult to explain Ben ads for the non-dutch speakers. Ben is a name, but ben also means 'am' , as in 'I am'. "I am Ben" is in dutch: "Ik ben Ben." Ben is also the name of a GSM provider. Ben©. Got it?

ben

Anyway, this is Henk & Ben©. Or so the line reads at the end. It's a ten second spot, where Henk is out walking his pet elephant -like you do- and he gets a phone-call on his Ben© phone. No words are spoken, just the line 'Henk&Ben©' flashes up at the end. All ads in this campaign have quirky people and their Ben© phones in everyday situations. (like out walking their pet elephant).....

Shot the 14th of May 1999 (Yes I know this for a fact!) the scripts were probably written in April or so, since even creative hot-shops like KesselsKramer (Amsterdam) follows some kind of routine. Creatives were Johan Kramer (Copy) and Erik Kessels (art). These ads were shot by Petterson&Åkerlund in Sweden. Next Victim ;

ben

Hi is another GSM-provider, (ads created by PMSY&R, Amsterdam) and they've been around for a while, streamlining their ads to be simple cartoons which only requires an idea, a Henry, a Henry-operator and a clever sound-guy. In other words, this could easily be done in a day.

ben

Look! There's another elephant! But here the voiceover says that you can bring Hi with you on your vacation, which may explain why the elephant is there. Tag-line is; Hi, keeps it simple.

Like I said, I'm pretty sure it was a complete coincidence. This is just a reminder that ideas , same or similar, do happen to pop into a lot of peoples heads at the same time, and not everything is a on purpose plagiarism. Funny that two creative teams made the connection cellphone+elephant though, but personally, I understand why it's in the Hi ad, but why is there a pet elephant in the Ben© ad? What do you think it is, a coincidence, or an alien conspiracy?

Those of you that have copies of the KesselsKramer book may notice that these screenshots look identical to theirs. Guess why.No, I didn't nick it - this was up before that book was even thought of, K? I did however empty all my floppies over at their office and donated a bunch thinking they might want them (me having a more modern machine that doesn't take no steenkin' floppies). Didn't realize they'd use the data on them. Oh well.

AnonymousCoward's picture
comment_node_story
Files must be less than 500 KB.
Allowed file types: jpg jpeg gif png txt doc xls pdf ppt pps odt ods odp wav avi mpeg mpg mov rm flv wmv 3gp mp4 dir dcr ogg m4v.

Adland is supported by your donations alone. You can help us out by donating via Liberapay, the Paypal button, or using our amazon affiliate links.