Both of these ads really suck.

Adland: 
Badland: 

They do - literally, even if they are both award winners and quite good. One won a gold in this years Cannes Festival for Outdoor. Read more to see the pair.

Client: Rowenta
Year: 2000
Found on: Cannes shortlist 2000
Creative Team: Fritz Ehlers, Katja Kloos, Stefan Herrmann
Agency: Publicis Werbeagentur

Client: Electrolux
Year: 2003
Source: Lion Cannes 2004 (Outdoor, Gold)
Creative Team: Peder Schack, Ole Caspersen
Agency: Young & Rubicam Copenhagen

By the way, this isn't the first time we've seen Y&R Copenhagen in Badland, they also did the grates in work for idle hands, last year. Is it becoming a habit?

* note - the "nothing sucks like an electrolux" legendary ad, sadly a misundersood myth, is clarified in the comments

Comments (15)

  • Imanaddy's picture
    Imanaddy

    ha-ha-ha-ha-ha-hacks!

    I think i've seen this before, somewhere 98 or 97, a poster with a vacuum attached to it "sucked onto it", very similar idea.

    Aug 04, 2004
  • kidkie's picture
    kidkie

    Oh. It reminded me about some stuff that I saw on Luerzersarchive.com a while ago. Um. Here's some newspaper ads that were made for Electrolux in 2003. "Really really very very strong very strong vacuum cleaner which is very very really strong.".

    http://hem.passagen.se/kidkie/ads/elec.html

    Client: Electrolux
    Agency: Scandinavian Design Group
    Art Director: Muggie Ramadani
    Photographer: Kenneth Godtfredsen

    Aug 05, 2004
  • Dabitch's picture
    Dabitch

    Wow, what a brainsync!

    I like those ads you show there, quite good.

    Aug 05, 2004
  • Neaner's picture
    Neaner

    The first poster is great, the ads kidkie shared are clever too, but I'm not so sure that gold-winning Cannes Outdoor advert wouldn't be mistaken for scaffolding-sheets torn in the wind, a very common sight where I am. Not worth a gold anyway, since the idea itself is dead old. Has Cannes jumped the shark?

    Aug 05, 2004
  • James_Trickery's picture
    James_Trickery

    Nice addition kidkie!

    What I don't understand is that the poster in 2000 didn't win, but four yeras later the same idea is worth a gold? Publicis Werbeagentur must feel pretty short-changed.

    Aug 06, 2004
  • caffeinegoddess's picture
    caffeinegoddess

    One thing I like about both ads is that they use the space well. Lots of ads in those kinds of spaces don't. Which is a shame.

    Aug 06, 2004
  • kidkie's picture
    kidkie

    I've gotta say that I like all of the creative. The way they used the media is awesome. It's not often you see creative billboards like the first one. I wish there was more of those around in Sweden. Usually they just blow up the press ads and post them. Intergrated campaigns ('disruption' as by TBWA) is often commented as the new thing (!?). What I've noticed is that most of the intregrated campaigns are faked. Just put all the creative in the same design and they pass. Big ideas where the initial idea/strategy runs through the whole campaign is still rare.
    Do you guy's have any examples of good integrated campaigns?

    Mini by Crispin, Porter & Bogusky!? I don't have any own references to this one. I've only seen it in award books...

    Aug 07, 2004
  • Dabitch's picture
    Dabitch

    Nope, it wasn't a myth and no, it did not run in the states and wasn't some badly translated "marketing mistake" as many people claim... Here's the legendary cheeky British "nothing sucks" ad, thanks Alex! sorry, poor photocopy - the image shows that Electrolux is the reason the leaning tower of Pisa, leans....

    Aug 30, 2004
  • Imanaddy's picture
    Imanaddy

    LOL! That's great - I'm beginning to think all of these ads suck. You can't tell one brand from the other.

    Aug 30, 2004
  • kamari's picture
    kamari

    Thank you - You've just settled a bet in my office ( I Won!).
    I knew that ad had run in the UK and not in the states!

    Oct 19, 2004
  • kamari's picture
    kamari

    ... and since both of them are clearly in the 'Outdoor' category... Well.. That is odd.

    Oct 19, 2004
  • Dabitch's picture
    Dabitch

    In the year end issue of Campaign they listed the Y&R Electrolux ad in sixth place on their list of great international outdoor ads.

    I guess they never saw the Rowenta one.

    Jan 07, 2005
  • joelapompe's picture
    joelapompe

    I love the title of your post :-)
    Let me offer you one more "russian" example of these sucking ideas.
    It's been done in 2005 and send to the Moscow ad fest!

    Jul 24, 2009
  • Dabitch's picture
    Dabitch

    Hehe. :) Nothing sucks like an Electrolux is my motto.

    Jul 24, 2009

Leave a comment

about the author

Dabitch Creative Director, CEO, hell-raising sweetheart and editor of Adland. Globetrotting Swede who has lived and worked in New York, London, San Francisco, Amsterdam, Copenhagen and Stockholm after growing up in Kiruna, Raleigh and Jiddah.